Seeking cost effect low, passenger side alternator mount ...?
May not be possible, but I'm looking for ideas re: a cost effective, low, passenger side alternator mount for my sbf.
Needs to be compatible with my existing reverse rotation water pump (Edelbrock 8840), my installed Ford OEM power steering unit, useable with the Edelbrock aluminum heads (Performer RPM), and ideally, with the rest of the front dress-up kit from CFR Performance.
1st picture shows the front of my engine with the "high" alternator mount that came with the CFR stuff.
2nd picture shows how Chris has his degas tank mounted (he doesn't have PS and appears to be using a standard rotation WP)
I recognize that I may need to add an idler for the serpentine belt - which will be OK as long as everything fits.
I hope I can accomplish this without need to scrap all of my CFR stuff, and end up having to buy a much more expensive (but admittedly very high quality) complete set-up from someone like March.
I've sent an inquiry to March Performance, but haven't heard back yet.
Mark at Breeze said he doesn't have anything, CFR said they can't help, and the alternator mount offered by Mike Everson at Replica parts apparently won't work either. Maybe the mount offered by Mike Forte will work --- will need to get hold of him and check ...
Seeking ideas, thoughts and helpful comments ...
Thanks in advance
Lynn
__________________
Retired and living in southern Utah where's it's warm and dry, and where every day is a good day as long as you wake up on top of the dirt!.
FFR 7591 Anniversary Edition (#10 of 15)
Build school: Feb. 2012, Order date: July '12, Delivery date: 23 Sept '12
How about if you swing the alternator down sort of like is shown in your photo of the V-belt setup? You'd have to run the tensioner rod (represented as the blue line in my crude sketch up) to pick up a water pump bolt or unused front cover boss, which could require a different length sleeve. Belt routing would be as shown in red. Would it work?
Heck, I don't know but you've got nothing to lose by experimenting with it!
I dont think you need to lower the alternator, I think the hose will clear the top of the alternator just fine. The hose on a stock 5.0 goes over the top. You can always raise the tank a small amount when you do the mock up for the tank bracket if you need to.
I didnt have much luck with the CFR alternator bracket either so I went with Kirkhams bracket. Heres my setup with the degas tank with Breeze upper hose, power steering and reverse rotation water pump.
FFR 7330 Delivered 9/18/10
Powdercoated silver & rolling 10/22/10
Machine work done on 331 2/3/11
Body Painted Raven Black 6/17/11
Wiring done 12/19/12
First Start and mini go-cart 1/1/2013
The problem with going with the low mount alt and reverse rotation pump is the belt wrap. Below is a pic of mine and you can see that without the idler the only belt route would mean the waterpump has almost no belt wrap (although 5.8Cobra's post would indicate it works). I had to custom make these (had them cut by a waterjet company) since I could not find anything that would work with this combo.
Rod,
I agree that the belt wrap might be an issue, however I have concerns about the crank rather than the water pump. The pump really doesn't take a trememdous amount of effort to drive but everything keys on the crank. FWIW, although I wondered if there was sufficient wrap on the crank pulley when I initially set it up I've flogged mine mercilessly without issues for ~14K miles using this "V" configuration.
Location: Blackberry Township, IL (west of Geneva)
Posts: 1,574
Lynn - FWIW, my brackets are as follows:
1) at the cylinder head, I used a 6" bolt and a stock '65 Mustang alternator spacer from National Parts Depot;
2) the lower tensioner bracket is from a 351 Cleveland that I shortened at the water pump end and then rebent to reverse the stock bends (cold bent on my Harbor Freight press); and
3) upper bracket is 3/16" plate aluminum that I cut based on a cardboard template, then I made some aluminum spacers to make it fit on the waterpump in the plane that I needed.
All of the brackets were based off the initial spacer and bolt on the head. In the end, I didn't need any spacers on the waterpump pulley to get the belt in perfect alignment. As long as the brackets hold the alternator solidly and offer the flexibility to adjust tension, you should be good. Although, I guess that you could add a tensioner/idler easy enough and avoid the hassle of making the alternator mount adjustable.
Keep us posted on your progress!
__________________
Later,
Chris
Mk3.1 #7074
Picked-up at FFR - 10/10/09
First start and go-kart - 9/19/12
"As smoke is blown away; so blow them away." Psalm 68:2
How about if you swing the alternator down sort of like is shown in your photo of the V-belt setup? You'd have to run the tensioner rod (represented as the blue line in my crude sketch up) to pick up a water pump bolt or unused front cover boss, which could require a different length sleeve. Belt routing would be as shown in red. Would it work?
Heck, I don't know but you've got nothing to lose by experimenting with it!
Good luck,
Jeff
Several great and helpful responses. I don't know how to do a multi-quote response on the computer - so I'll respond to a couple individually.
Jeff - I did initially look at just dropping the alternator on the CFR bracket but got very concerned by what looked like insufficient belt contact with the water pump pulley.
But based on Mike's experience/comment by Mike (5.8Cobra), I need to go back and re-look at this possibility.
Thanks
__________________
Retired and living in southern Utah where's it's warm and dry, and where every day is a good day as long as you wake up on top of the dirt!.
FFR 7591 Anniversary Edition (#10 of 15)
Build school: Feb. 2012, Order date: July '12, Delivery date: 23 Sept '12
I didnt have much luck with the CFR alternator bracket either so I went with Kirkhams bracket. Heres my setup with the degas tank with Breeze upper hose, power steering and reverse rotation water pump.
Mike
Mike -
Safe to assume that you've got adequate cooling with your set up? My concern would be the amount of belt/water pump pulley contact. (As a side-bar on the cooling question - I live in southern Utah (St George) and it gets powerful warm (hot) around here in the summer time.)
In my searching for a solution on the Forum, I did run across a comment re: the Kirkham bracket - possibly from you - but when I went to the Kirkham site to look for it, I didn't see much that was of any help. Any chance you've got a link to the Kirkham bracket ....?
Many thanks
Lynn
__________________
Retired and living in southern Utah where's it's warm and dry, and where every day is a good day as long as you wake up on top of the dirt!.
FFR 7591 Anniversary Edition (#10 of 15)
Build school: Feb. 2012, Order date: July '12, Delivery date: 23 Sept '12
1) at the cylinder head, I used a 6" bolt and a stock '65 Mustang alternator spacer from National Parts Depot;
2) the lower tensioner bracket is from a 351 Cleveland that I shortened at the water pump end and then rebent to reverse the stock bends (cold bent on my Harbor Freight press); and
3) upper bracket is 3/16" plate aluminum that I cut based on a cardboard template, then I made some aluminum spacers to make it fit on the waterpump in the plane that I needed.
All of the brackets were based off the initial spacer and bolt on the head. In the end, I didn't need any spacers on the waterpump pulley to get the belt in perfect alignment. As long as the brackets hold the alternator solidly and offer the flexibility to adjust tension, you should be good. Although, I guess that you could add a tensioner/idler easy enough and avoid the hassle of making the alternator mount adjustable.
Keep us posted on your progress!
Chris -
Thanks 1st of all for posting the details of your "degas tank" mod that got me to where I am today
Like I read somewhere ... "Bolt-on's often don't"
But despite the difficulties I'm encountering, I think it's a great mod!
Thanks for sharing the details for sourcing of your pulleys and brackets.
My only two concerns with adapting what you've done are:
1) sourcing (and mounting) of an idler, and
2) the need to custom fab one of the brackets since my fab skills are NOT the greatest. With this part of the engine being right out in front where everyone can see it, I'm not anxious to have a DIY and possibly "hack-job" bracket being so "up close and personal".
I will post up what I eventually end up with.
Thanks again
Lynn
__________________
Retired and living in southern Utah where's it's warm and dry, and where every day is a good day as long as you wake up on top of the dirt!.
FFR 7591 Anniversary Edition (#10 of 15)
Build school: Feb. 2012, Order date: July '12, Delivery date: 23 Sept '12
I am not up and running with this combo yet but I used to run a short belt on my Mustang that bypassed the smog, PS and AC which had even less wrap on the water pump and it cooled fine. I do see what everyone is saying about wrap around the crank. I plan on trying it this way and if it squeals I will revisit it then. Its not a problem til its a problem! I got the bracket off of ebay a couple years back but I am sure they still have them. Maybe give them a call, they were great to deal with on ebay.
FFR 7330 Delivered 9/18/10
Powdercoated silver & rolling 10/22/10
Machine work done on 331 2/3/11
Body Painted Raven Black 6/17/11
Wiring done 12/19/12
First Start and mini go-cart 1/1/2013
I did initially look at just dropping the alternator on the CFR bracket but got very concerned by what looked like insufficient belt contact with the water pump pulley.
But based on Mike's experience/comment by Mike (5.8Cobra), I need to go back and re-look at this possibility.
Just as a point of reference Lynn, there are a bunch of cars out there using the Breeze driver's side mount successfully. As you can see the belt just kind of kisses the WP pulley:
As I said above my concern would not be the WP but rather having sufficient wrap on the crank to avoid slippage on it since it has to drive the accessories.
Just as a point of reference Lynn, there are a bunch of cars out there using the Breeze driver's side mount successfully. As you can see the belt just kind of kisses the WP pulley:
As I said above my concern would not be the WP but rather having sufficient wrap on the crank to avoid slippage on it since it has to drive the accessories.
Jeff
You're right - I hadn't noticed or paid much attention to the crank-belt contact which is the critical area.
It sometimes takes giving me a "whack-upside-the-head" to get me to notice things - but I got it now!
Thanks
Lynn
__________________
Retired and living in southern Utah where's it's warm and dry, and where every day is a good day as long as you wake up on top of the dirt!.
FFR 7591 Anniversary Edition (#10 of 15)
Build school: Feb. 2012, Order date: July '12, Delivery date: 23 Sept '12
Here's a shot of my upper hose to give you an idea of the clearance at the alternator using a similar set up to your engine. Might be just enough room for the de-gas tank?
I have very little belt wrap on my water pump pulley, and no issues whatsoever with belt slipping,, etc. and that's with an underdrive crank pulley. (I have since changed pulley and fan, as I hated that black plastic fan.) Alternator charges fine as well.
So have been playing and mocking a tank up for my spec racer and using the March 87-93 alternator mount seems like enough clearance. Taking a slightly different approach in replacing the current big block water neck adapter with a small block water neck adapter thus using the existing mounting (just different water neck and turned 180 degrees).
__________________
Tony Nadalin
MKII Challenge Car, Spec Racer, Street Legal, 302 EFI, 3 Link, ICSCC, NASA and SCCA Racing
2012 ICSCC ITE Class Champion My Garage
Welcome to FFCars! The
representations expressed are the representations and opinions of
the FFCars.com forum members and do not necessarily reflect the
opinions and viewpoints of the site owners, moderators, Factory Five
Racing, Inc. or Ford Motor Company. This website
has been planned and developed by FFCars.com and its forum members
and should not be construed as being endorsed by Factory Five
Racing, Inc. or Ford Motor Company for any
purpose. "FFR", "Factory Five", "Factory Five Racing", and the
Factory Five Racing logo are registered trademarks of Factory Five
Racing, Inc. FFCars.com forum members agree not to
post any copyrighted material unless the copyrighted material is
owned by you. Although we do not and cannot review the messages
posted and are not responsible for the content of any of these
messages, we reserve the right to delete any message for any reason
whatsoever. You remain solely responsible for the content of your
messages, and you agree to indemnify and hold us harmless with
respect to any claim based upon transmission of your message(s).
Thank you for visiting the FFCars.com Forum dedicated to Factory
Five.